[fitsbits] BINTABLE convention for >999 columns
Francois-Xavier PINEAU
francois-xavier.pineau at astro.unistra.fr
Fri Jul 7 10:46:37 EDT 2017
Dear all,
First, thank you very much for this mail Mark.
As you wrote, I 'favour a different mechanism for encoding the extended
column metadata'.
Here my suggestion:
I propose to use a mechanism like HIERARCH, maybe the HIERACH keyword
itself or an OVERLOAD keyword (or something similar).
Often, when a software reads metadata, it puts FITS cards into a map
having for key the card keyword.
I propose something like:
TFIELDS = 999 / For HIERARCH unaware readers
HIERARCH TFIELDS 1204 / For HIERARCH aware readers
...
TTYPE999= 'XT_MORECOLS' / For HIERARCH unaware readers
TFORM999= '813I ' / For HIERARCH unaware readers
HIERARCH TTYPE999 'var_min_u_2' / For HIERARCH aware readers
HIERARCH TFORM999 'D' / For HIERARCH aware readers
HIERARCH TTYPE1000 'var_prob_h_2' / For HIERARCH aware readers
HIERARCH TFORM1000 'D' / For HIERARCH aware readers
...
Then, the keyword of the card
HIERARCH TFIELDS 1204
is TFIELDS and, if put in a map, the (object containing the) value 1204
will overload the previous value (i.e. 999).
Similarly, the keyword of the card
HIERARCH TTYPE999 'var_min_u_2'
is TTYPE999 and, if put in map, the value 'var_min_u_2' will overload
the previous value of TTYPE999 (i.e. 'XT_MORECOLS').
*If a FITS reader uses maps to store FITS cards and is HIERARCH aware,
then **
**it should be able to load tables with more than 999 rows without
changing or adding a single line of code!*
Le 07/07/2017 à 13:09, Mark Taylor a écrit :
> Dear fitsbits,
>
> I am considering a convention for storing table data in FITS files
> where the number of columns exceeds the 999 limit implicitly imposed
> by the standard BINTABLE extension type. I have running code for
> this (available on request) and plan to incorporate it in future
> releases of STIL/STILTS/TOPCAT so that people can work with wide
> tables in FITS while using those tools. People using software
> that is unaware of this convention would still see a legal BINTABLE
> but not the later columns.
>
> I'm posting the details here in case people want to comment,
> or point out some major problem with the idea that I might have
> overlooked, or tell me that there's already a convention for
> this out there that I should be using instead. Otherwise, please
> feel free to ignore this post. I'm not requesting that any
> other software implements this, though if anyone wants to I
> certainly don't object.
>
> Mark
>
> . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
>
> Extended column convention for FITS BINTABLE
> --------------------------------------------
>
> The BINTABLE extension type as described in the FITS Standard
> (FITS Standard v3.0, sec 7.3) requires table column metadata
> to be described using 8-character keywords of the form XXXXXnnn,
> where XXXXX represents one of an open set of mandatory, reserved
> or user-defined root keywords up to five characters in length,
> for instance TFORM (mandatory), TUNIT (reserved), TUCD (user-defined).
> The nnn part is an integer between 1 and 999 indicating the
> index of the column to which the keyword in question refers.
> Since the header syntax confines this indexed part of the keyword
> to three digits, there is an upper limit of 999 columns in
> BINTABLE extensions.
>
> Note that the FITS/BINTABLE format does not entail any restriction on
> the storage of column *data* beyond the 999 column limit in the data
> part of the HDU, the problem is just that client software
> cannot be informed about the layout of this data using the
> header cards in the usual way.
>
> In some cases it is desirable to store FITS tables with a column
> count greater than 999. Whether that's a good idea is not within
> the scope of this discussion.
>
> To achieve this, I propose the following convention.
>
> Definitions:
>
> - 'BINTABLE columns' are those columns defined using the
> FITS BINTABLE standard
>
> - 'Data columns' are the columns to be encoded
>
> - N_TOT is the total number of data columns to be stored
>
> - Data columns with (1-based) indexes from 999 to N_TOT inclusive
> are known as 'extended' columns. Their data is stored
> within the 'container' column.
>
> - BINTABLE column 999 is known as the 'container' column
> It contains the byte data for all the 'extended' columns.
>
> Convention:
>
> - All column data (for columns 1 to N_TOT) is laid out in the data part
> of the HDU in exactly the same way as if there were no 999-column
> limit.
>
> - The TFIELDS header is declared with the value 999.
>
> - The container column is declared in the header with some
> TFORM999 value corresponding to the total field length required
> by all the extended columns ('B' is the obvious data type, but
> any legal TFORM value that gives the right width MAY be used).
> The byte count implied by TFORM999 MUST be equal to the
> total byte count implied by all extended columns.
>
> - Other XXXXX999 headers MAY optionally be declared to describe
> the container column in accordance with the usual rules,
> e.g. TTYPE999 to give it a name.
>
> - The NAXIS1 header is declared in the usual way to give the width
> of a table row in bytes. This is equal to the sum of
> all the BINTABLE columns as usual. It is also equal to
> the sum of all the data columns, which has the same value.
>
> - Headers for Data columns 1-998 are declared as usual,
> corresponding to BINTABLE columns 1-998.
>
> - Keyword XT_ICOL indicates the index of the container column.
> It MUST be present with the integer value 999 to indicate
> that this convention is in use.
>
> - Keyword XT_NCOL indicates the total number of data columns encoded.
> It MUST be present with an integer value equal to N_TOT.
>
> - Metadata for each extended column is encoded with keywords
> of the form XXXXXaaa, where XXXXX are the same keyword roots
> as used for normal BINTABLE extensions, and aaa is a 3-digit
> value in base 26 using the characters 'A' (0 in base 26) to
> 'Z' (25 in base 26), and giving the 1-based data column index
> minus 999. The sequence aaa MUST be exactly three characters
> long (leading 'A's are required). Thus the formats for data
> columns 999, 1000, 1001, etc are declared with the keywords
> TFORMAAA, TFORMAAB, TFORMAAC etc.
>
> - This convention MUST NOT be used for N_TOT<=999.
>
> The resulting HDU is a completely legal FITS BINTABLE extension.
> Readers aware of this convention may use it to extract column
> data and metadata beyond the 999-column limit.
> Readers unaware of this convention will see 998 columns in their
> intended form, and an additional (possibly large) column 999
> which contains byte data but which cannot be easily interpreted.
>
> This convention can therefore allow encoding of tables with data
> column counts N_TOT up to 998+26^3 = 18574.
>
> An example header might look like this:
>
> XTENSION= 'BINTABLE' / binary table extension
> BITPIX = 8 / 8-bit bytes
> NAXIS = 2 / 2-dimensional table
> NAXIS1 = 9229 / width of table in bytes
> NAXIS2 = 26 / number of rows in table
> PCOUNT = 0 / size of special data area
> GCOUNT = 1 / one data group
> TFIELDS = 999 / number of columns
> XT_ICOL = 999 / index of container column
> XT_NCOL = 1204 / total columns including extended
> TTYPE1 = 'posid_1 ' / label for column 1
> TFORM1 = 'J ' / format for column 1
> TTYPE2 = 'instrument_1' / label for column 2
> TFORM2 = '4A ' / format for column 2
> TTYPE3 = 'edge_code_1' / label for column 3
> TFORM3 = 'I ' / format for column 3
> TUCD3 = 'meta.code.qual'
> ...
> TTYPE998= 'var_min_s_2' / label for column 998
> TFORM998= 'D ' / format for column 998
> TUNIT998= 'counts/s' / units for column 998
> TTYPE999= 'XT_MORECOLS' / label for column 999
> TFORM999= '813I ' / format for column 999
> TTYPEAAA= 'var_min_u_2' / label for column 999
> TFORMAAA= 'D ' / format for column 999
> TUNITAAA= 'counts/s' / units for column 999
> TTYPEAAB= 'var_prob_h_2' / label for column 1000
> TFORMAAB= 'D ' / format for column 1000
> ...
> TTYPEAHW= 'var_prob_w_2' / label for column 1203
> TFORMAHW= 'D ' / format for column 1203
> TTYPEAHX= 'var_sigma_w_2' / label for column 1204
> TFORMAHX= 'D ' / format for column 1204
> TUNITAHX= 'counts/s' / units for column 1204
> END
>
> This general approach was suggested by William Pence on the FITSBITS
> list in June 2012
> (https://listmgr.nrao.edu/pipermail/fitsbits/2012-June/002367.html),
> and by Francois-Xavier Pineau (CDS) in private conversation in 2016.
> The details have been filled in by Mark Taylor (Bristol).
> (F-X favours a different mechanism for encoding the extended
> column metadata).
>
> --
> Mark Taylor Astronomical Programmer Physics, Bristol University, UK
> m.b.taylor at bris.ac.uk +44-117-9288776 http://www.star.bris.ac.uk/~mbt/
>
> _______________________________________________
> fitsbits mailing list
> fitsbits at listmgr.nrao.edu
> https://listmgr.nrao.edu/mailman/listinfo/fitsbits
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://listmgr.nrao.edu/pipermail/fitsbits/attachments/20170707/64914140/attachment-0001.html>
More information about the fitsbits
mailing list